Saturday, September 18, 2010

CSRF On The Rise

If you have heard any of my talks in 2010 you know how scary CSRF (Cross-Site Request Forgery) is and how I think it will be taking off and going from #5 in the OWASP Top 10 to #3 (hard to top SQL Injection and XSS at #1 and #2). It hasn't gotten a lot of press, and there hasn't been a ton of action on that front by the bad guys...yet.

But this week an article in DarkReading about CSRF came out that shows it is starting to increase. My comment at the bottom of the article should sound familiar to those of you watching this blog (I think there are 4 or 5 of you out there, right? ) -- the press and the noise is still about patching and server-side, network-facing solutions. They are band-aids and stitches fixing holes that will continue and continue until developers learn to code more securely.

"Blah blah blah" some of you may be saying. "Same old same old. Show us something more, Greg." Well, if you thought that, or said it out loud, I have to ask "Are you actively coding against SQL Injection and Cross-site Scripting?" If you are, and my spiel sounds old, then it is time to move on away from here. And CONGRATULATIONS, Grasshopper! You have become a better developer and that is a success for us both in my book!

For the rest of you, please dig in. Read my previous posts and go to sites like OWASP and and see how to code against SQL Injection and Cross-site scripting. These two things alone will help us all.

So what about CSRF? What can I do about it? The short answer is that the hole is plugged at the destination of the attack, and that is by validating all actionable requests thoroughly. Huh? I will do more posts about CSRF, what it is, how it works, but in general it is that you have to make sure requests come from someone you know already, that has logged in and has a specific signature or footprint so you know every request that comes from that person. Analogy time -- if someone came to your door, 6 ft and blonde, and hands you their username and password, then you can generate a ticket and session for them. If someone 5' and brunette comes to the door with the first person's ticket, is it the first person? Obviously not, but our web servers only look at the ticket! If you have the ticket you MUST be the right person. Ouch! This is what makes CSRF work, executing an action on someone else's behalf. So the solution is to look for the 6ft blonde on each request using that ticket. For you .NET folks that solution is via the ViewStateUserKey. ViewStateUserKey can be set to the session id of the current user and that will be enough to show the server it really is the right person. The hacker won't have viewstate in a link, and if they try to create a whole form to do the work it won't have the current session in it. Ahhh...much better! (Side note about it not being perfect found in this article.)

So now maybe I will have to harp on proper CSRF coding as well as SQLi and XSS...

No comments:

Post a Comment